Mothering Sunday: Sacrifice and hope

Sermons

Mothering Sunday: Sacrifice and hope

Published: 9th December, 2025

Mothering Sunday
Exodus 2.1-10
2 Corinthians 1.3-7
Psalm 34.11-20
John 19.25b-27

In the name of the +Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen.

It seems to me that we’ve got ourselves into a tremendous pickle about motherhood and family life more generally.  It’s quite hard to understand how something so basic and fundamental to human society should have become so complicated and contested.  No doubt it is yet another sign of that disconnection from nature, disconnection from ourselves, and disconnection from God that I talked about last Sunday.

For many years we talked about parenting as if it were primarily a matter of personal fulfilment for the parent.  Some people still do talk in this way.  People talk about having children as if it were a right; and in some quarters there is a growing assumption that society has an obligation to assist people to have children in various ways.  And whilst that might be appropriate in some situations, framing having children as a right from the point-of-view of would-be parents risks giving insufficient weight both to the needs of the people being asked to do the assisting, and also to the needs of the children themselves.

And in recent years a strange thing has happened: people have begun to stop having children.  This is often seen primarily as an economic problem: goodness knows who’s going to pay for my old age pension!  And of course it is that, but I don’t think that’s the main problem.  It speaks to me of a deep social and cultural crisis, and perhaps above all a crisis of hope.

If parenting is understood as primarily a matter of personal fulfilment for the parents, it’s not especially surprising that people are having fewer children, and more and more people are not having children at all.  Psychological research confirms what the two women in this morning’s bible readings could tell us: parenting, and I suspect motherhood especially, is very largely a matter of anxiety rather than fulfilment, and it comes with a lot of sacrifice and pain.  It’s rare to find a mother who has stopped worrying about her children.  Of course there are all manner of wonderful things about being a parent too, but according to the cold logic of economic utility, having children looks like a strange choice.  And so when the decision to be a parent is understood as a matter of personal fulfilment in much the same way as changing career, booking a holiday or redecorating your house, it’s really no wonder that young people are less and less interested in having children.

I’m sure I comment every year on the stark contrast between the sentimentality of Mother’s Day in the world of greetings cards and restaurant bookings, and the gritty reality of the readings set by the Church for Mothering Sunday.

Thanks to the genocidal command of Pharaoh, Moses’ mother makes a desperate attempt to save him from death.  She builds a little basket to protect him as best she can, and she pushes him out into the waters of the Nile.  She experiences in the most brutal way what is an important part of the experience of most mothers: for a child to flourish, a mother must learn to let go.  It doesn’t normally come all at once as it does for Moses’ mother.  But from the first separations of childcare or school, through to moving away and building an adult life, the child must be allowed to go their own way.  And there is often a painful element of separation and even rejection in that process.  Of course there is a fulfilment for the parent in seeing the child flourishing and independent.  But there is also a sense of loss.

The situation of Mary at the foot of the Cross is starker still.  The sense of separation and loss is absolute, and combined with her own powerlessness it is hard to imagine anything worse.  And Jesus’ words can’t have helped, appearing at least to focus on Mary’s practical need rather than her inner life.

And yet there is hope in both these stories.

Through his mother’s brave act in letting go of her son, giving him up to the waters of the Nile, Moses not only survives, he goes on to become the liberator of his people from slavery in Egypt.

And so too through Mary’s courage first revealed in the words “let it be according to your word”, a courage that reaches its painful fulfilment at the foot of the cross, Jesus is revealed as the universal liberator of humanity from sin and death.

For neither woman is motherhood a matter of personal fulfilment.  Motherhood is rather a gift they give to others; motherhood is rather a sacrifice they make for the good of others.  Children are a gift from God to the mother, but they are also a gift from the mother to the wider community, where the child will grow to take their own place and make their own contribution.

Motherhood is a gift and a sacrifice, and it is also an act and a sign of hope.  Moses’ mother pushes him out into the waters in the desperate hope that he may have a chance and survive, and that hope is fulfilled beyond her expectations as he not only survives but leads his people out of the despair of slavery in Egypt and into the promised land.

Jesus’ birth is accompanied by hopeful promises of deliverance, and for Mary too that hope is fulfilled beyond her expectations, although only after the crushing desolation of the Cross.

But any child is a sign of hope, a sign of belief in our own families, our own society, our own community; a sign of hope in humanity.  Giving birth to any child is a commitment to the future, and to a sense of a shared story that will continue to unfold.

So this Mothering Sunday, as we give thanks for our mothers and acknowledge their struggles and sacrifices, let’s also try to step away from the shallow sentimentalism of the commercial Mother’s Day.  Instead let’s reconnect our thinking about motherhood and family life both with a deeper reflection on the place of families within a healthy society, and above all with the hope that humanity has in Jesus Christ, son of God and son of Mary, to whom with the +Father and the Holy Spirit be all praise and glory now and unto ages of ages.  Amen.