The Civic Service: “Keep religion out of politics!”

Sermons

The Civic Service: “Keep religion out of politics!”

Published: 6th January, 2026

In the name of the +Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen.

We’ve all heard the slogan “keep religion out of politics”.  What do we think it means?

There is after all a very obvious overlap between religion and politics.  Both are concerned with human flourishing, both are concerned with answering questions about what it means to live a good life, and how our life together can be best organised to allow a genuine human flourishing.  Both are concerned with questions of right and wrong.  And so it would be quite strange for religion to have nothing to say about politics, or, for that matter, for politics to have nothing to say about religion.  And of course even a fairly cursory knowledge of history reveals that the two are often very deeply intertwined.

“Keep religion out of politics” is a slogan that has its roots in the religious conflicts of the seventeenth century.  As the coercive apparatus of the state was used across Europe to persecute Protestants or Catholics or the “wrong” variety of Protestants, depending on where you lived, the idea emerged that the state should take a neutral stance in matters of religion.  This was put into practice in the eighteenth century in America and in revolutionary France – I think it’s fair to say with rather mixed results!  England took a very different approach – and I say England advisedly, because the constitutional setup is a little different in different parts of the United Kingdom.  Just as one might argue that our constitutional monarchy gives us, amongst other things, a sort of pretend dictator to protect us from ever feeling the need to have a real one, so too one might argue that having a sort of official channel to connect religion and politics protects us from the more dangerous sorts of religious influence over politics that at times have plagued other countries.

And sometimes I think the slogan “keep religion out of politics” has come to mean something quite different than making the case for an institutional separation of church and state.  In fact the cynic in me sometimes thinks that the slogan “keep religion out of politics” means little more than “keep opinions I don’t like out of politics”!

You can find Christians on different sides of practically every significant debate in modern British politics.  Christians disagree with one another about assisted dying, about immigration, about taxation and economic policy, and so on and so on.  All the major political parties will attract the votes of Christians.  And so you might start to think that the Christian faith, and Christian reflection on politics, is all a bit of a waste of time.  What’s the point of it if it leads to people believing in and arguing for completely different things?

Well for what it’s worth, although the Christian faith is of course about much more than politics, I think there are some useful things that Christian faith can offer when reflecting on public life.  We can’t go through all of them now, but perhaps I can outline a few things that seem to me to be important in our present time.

One is humility.  Christians believe both that we are made in the image of God, and also that we are fatally flawed and have a tendency to veer off in selfish and destructive directions.  We believe that at our best we are capable of great good, but that we should also never underestimate our capacity for evil, nor our capacity to delude ourselves about what is right.  An authentically Christian politics would be one that recognised that we do not have all the answers, and that all too often our attempts to construct heaven on earth lead us to the other place.  And so an authentically Christian politics would be one that was open to debate and dialogue, humble enough to accept that we don’t have all the answers and that we might sometimes, often, get things badly wrong.

Another is judgement – God’s judgement, not ours.  It’s not a concept that is terribly popular, but it is important.  The judgement of God is a central concept in Christian faith.  Every variety of leadership and authority on earth we believe is held in trust from God.  Each one of us, we believe, will face judgement at the end; each one of us who holds any kind of authority, whether in church or state or even in the workplace, will be called to give an account before God.  This is a pretty daunting thought, if we take it seriously.  It’s related to the point about humility: the concept of judgement keeps us, or ought to keep us, from getting above ourselves, from thinking too much of ourselves, and from becoming blasé about the decisions we make and the impact they have on others.

Another is service.  In John’s gospel Jesus washes the disciples’ feet.  He is their teacher and their Lord, and yet He puts Himself in the lowest place, and does the job that would usually have been done by a servant or slave.  And Jesus says quite explicitly that if you want to be great you must be a servant.  The last will be first, and the first last.  And so we do not expect our politicians nor for that matter our clergy to be in it for what they can get out of it, nor do we expect them to be in it for the pleasure of ordering other people about.  Leadership is understood as service.

Another is sacrifice.  This is coming into increasingly sharp focus.  To be a politician in today’s climate means being a target for all sorts of abuse.  Politicians at every level will get a lot of stick on social media.  And in the traditional media too.  Some of it, perhaps most of it, will be quite unfair.  But it’s not only that.  Political leadership means becoming a sort of public person, sacrificing quite a large element of personal privacy; it means being harangued in Tesco about potholes, it means the risk of some unguarded or unfortunate moment ending up in the newspapers, it sometimes means a loss of privacy for your loved ones as well as for yourselves.  And more than that, we are increasingly conscious of more serious risks.  Political violence in America has been in the news this past week, but we are not completely immune to these problems in our own political culture.  And yet for Christians this is a part of the nature of leadership.  We look to Jesus who was willing to lay down His life for His friends, and we say that a part of leadership is a willingness to put the common good before ourselves.

And then finally, as we heard in all our readings from the Bible this morning, there is concern for the poor.  The owner of the vineyard will not pay the workers less than the living wage, not even the ones who have only worked an hour.  St Paul in his Second Letter to the Corinthians encourages the Christians at Corinth to be generous to the poor.  And Moses in the Book of Deuteronomy instructs the Israelites to be open-handed to those who are poor and needy in their land.  Christians can reasonably disagree about how best to help the poor.  There are conservative Christians who are sceptical about the ability of the state to relieve poverty through taxation and spending, and who believe in the power of free markets to advance prosperity, but who are personally generous in supporting charities.  And there are Christian socialists who forcefully advocate for exactly the sorts of tax and spending policies that conservative Christians oppose.  And of course there are plenty of Christians whose views fall somewhere in the middle.  But whatever the case, any kind of Christian politics must have an overriding concern for the welfare of the poor.  Care for the poor is not an optional extra for Christians: as we have heard this morning, it runs right the way through the Bible.

Humility, God’s judgement, service, sacrifice, concern for the poor.  There are other things we could add, such as respect for truth and reverence for human life.  Whatever your views may be about the relationship between religion and politics, whatever you may think about the institutional separation of church and state, or the lack of it, whatever your faith, I hope that these biblical values can be helpful to all of us in reflecting on leadership and public life.

In the name of the +Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen.

Photograph by N Chadwick.