The Fifth Sunday after Trinity
Sunday 30th June 2024
2 Samuel 1:1,17- end
Psalm 130
Mark 5:21- end
In the name of the +Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen
I suppose I have rather more to do with death than most people of my age. Last Friday was a particularly extreme example: my morning was spent at the bedside of a lady who was once a regular worshipper here at St Mary’s who is now reaching the end of her earthly journey; at 12noon we had a Requiem Mass, at which we remembered before God the recently departed and those whose anniversaries of death fall in the month of June; and in the afternoon I made two visits to people who had recently lost love ones to plan the funerals. This of course is not typical; but nevertheless I have certainly been to many more funerals in the last few years than most people go to in a lifetime; and likewise I have been with people close to the end of life on many more occasions that most people would experience.
It would be nice to think that all these encounters with death in my working life would make it easier for me to accept death whenever I encounter it in a more personal context, and even my own death. But honestly I have no idea if it will be so. There is something very absolute about time. What is gone is gone. It lives on to some degree in memory perhaps, but that is often unreliable, and what we forget greatly outweighs what we remember. We must accept that loss, grief and sorrow are an inescapable and natural part of human life, and there is no point in trying to play it down or make out that it is something less than it is.
I have to confess a certain frustration with the Old Testament reading set for today. It is of course a great passage, David’s lament for the deaths of Saul and his sons. But you will remember that last Sunday we heard the story of David and Goliath, and many of you will realise that we have jumped over a considerable quantity of narrative, including many important stories that are crucial to understanding what is so poignant about David’s lament.
Hopefully many of you will remember the stories of David and Saul from Sunday school days, and others perhaps will have read them in personal bible study. But for everyone else I will give a very quick overview to help you make sense of the passage we heard this morning.
After David’s killing of Goliath, the story the story continues with the growing jealousy of King Saul towards David. But it also tells of the intense friendship that develops between David and Saul’s son Jonathan. Saul’s hostility forces David to leave the court and live the life of a wandering outlaw, gathering around him a group of desperate men who fight for him. David and Jonathan are separated in a poignant and tearful scene. Saul for his part becomes a tragic figure, rejected by the Prophet Samuel and the Lord, and he is killed with his sons by the Philistines at the Battle of Gilboa.
Dealing with death can be a complex matter. It is complex because human relationships are complex. David’s lament for Saul and Jonathan comes out of just such a complex place, as you will probably realise from my little summary. Saul had been a sort of substitute father for the young David. The one a young man, the other in middle age, they had been close. David had played the harp for Saul to sooth his troubled spirit; David had been the leader of Saul’s armies; David was also Saul’s son-in-law through his marriage to Saul’s daughter. And yet Saul had turned against David and sought to kill him, and hunted him down like a criminal. Now Saul is dead, and David mourns him, glossing over the very obvious strains in their relationship.
This is very familiar to me from funerals; so often it is the things that are not said that I need to watch out for. And I am sure that many of you with experiences of loss will know how difficult it can be to combine a sense of respect for the dead with honesty about the challenges and hurt of strained relationships. Perhaps it might be an encouragement to know that this too has its place within the bible and within the tradition of Christian faith.
But David’s words of lament for Jonathan are of a very different nature to his words about Saul.
I am distressed for you, my brother Jonathan; greatly beloved were you to me; your love to me was wonderful, passing the love of women.
Whilst David’s words about Saul have a formal quality, and are primarily encouraging others to grieve for him, David’s words about Jonathan are strikingly personal. It is in this part of the lament that David switches into the first person. “O daughters of Israel, weep for Saul”, David sings. But for Jonathan the language shifts to I and you: “I am distressed for you, my brother Jonathan; greatly beloved were you to me”. In the case of Saul there is the complexity of grief that relates to a difficult relationship with a deeply flawed and troubled man, a grief that can only find an outlet in detached, formalized language. In the case of Jonathan there is the direct simplicity of the grief of the loss of a beloved friend, a relationship untainted by jealousy, violence and betrayal.
There is no soft-pedalling here about the harsh reality of death and the sorrow of separation. Lament is an important part of the bible and of the Christian tradition; in lamentation we give voice to the full force of our sorrow and grief. This is a natural and healthy part of grieving.
Your glory O Israel lies slain in high places.
One story of a king killed on a mountain connects us with another. King Saul dies on Mount Gilboa; Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews, as Pilate’s inscription has it, dies on the hill of Calvary. Today’s gospel reminds us that Jesus has power over both life and death. And yet Jesus also must face death in the fulness of His humanity, weeping at the grave of Lazarus, and wrestling painfully with His fate in the Garden of Gethsemane. We need feel no shame in being afraid of death. Jesus Himself on one level did not want to die and was afraid. “Take this cup from me”, He pleads with the Father, “yet not my will, but yours be done”.
Jesus must face death in the fulness of His humanity. And in the fulness of His Divinity, God in Jesus embraces humanity in all its frailty, embracing even death itself. Death is a real separation from a human perspective but it is not a separation from God. When we walk through the valley of the shadow of death He is with us. We wait for the Lord, more than the night watch for the morning. In Jesus the God in whom we live and move and have our being, the God in whom all times are held, in Jesus God who is beyond both time and space enters into both time and space, the Creator becomes a creature. And on the Cross righteousness becomes sin and life becomes death. This fallen and broken world is turned upside down and inside out. And through this shocking and violent death comes a triumph; Jesus says: “I was dead, and see, I am alive forever and ever, and I have the keys of Death and of Hades.”
I am not here to sugar-coat death for you. Yes it is often peaceful, yes it is often a release, but it is always a separation and a loss, and there is no shame in grief and sorrow. But we face that loss and grief and sorrow with courage and even in hope, because God in Jesus has taken our human frailty and even our mortality into Himself and triumphed over it. In Jesus we share in communion with the church living and departed, united through time and space, and we hope that as we are united with Him in a death like His, so too we will be united with Him and with the whole Church in His glorious Resurrection, to whom with the +Father and the Holy Spirit be all praise and glory now and unto ages of ages. Amen.
