The Second Sunday of Lent: Caustic and Compassionate

Sermons

The Second Sunday of Lent: Caustic and Compassionate

Published: 5th December, 2025

The Second Sunday of Lent
Genesis 15.1-12,17-18
Romans 10.8b-13
Psalm 27
Luke 13.31-end

In the name of the +Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen.

I find this morning’s gospel to be a fascinating little passage.  Jesus’ use of language drawn from the animal kingdom immediately puts us in mind of the world of Aesop’s fables or the Proverbs of the Old Testament, which frequently use the animal kingdom to critique some aspect of human behaviour, or to impart a moral warning.  In this gospel passage we can already feel the shadow of the Cross, as Jesus tells the Pharisees that it is impossible for a prophet to be killed outside Jerusalem.  And two contrasting sides, two apparently contradictory facets, of Jesus’ character are revealed.

If we work backwards, we will notice Jesus’ deeply compassionate stance towards the city of Jerusalem and its people.

Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! How often have I desired to gather your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!

Jesus speaks of Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets, the city where He will suffer and die, as a mother might speak of a wayward child.  Parents of teenagers will likely understand these words.  Our urge to protect is strong, and yet we know too that we must allow growth, and that for there to be growth there must be a level of freedom and independence.  So too Jesus wishes to protect the people of Jerusalem, but He will not compel.  When He comes to Jerusalem, He will come in humility.

The maternal imagery in Jesus’ words is striking.  He clearly wishes to indicate the depth of His compassion by using this unexpected language.  Language about God in the bible is very largely male, but Jesus’ use of maternal imagery is not altogether unprecedented.  We find such language particularly in the later part of the prophecy of Isaiah.  For example, the Lord says through the prophet: “Can a woman forget her nursing child, or show no compassion for the child of her womb? Even these may forget, yet I will not forget you.”  And so it may be that by reaching for this maternal language, Jesus is laying claim to a Hebrew tradition of speaking about God, and hinting at His own divinity.

The message is clear enough: Jesus compares Himself to a mother hen to reveal the depth of His compassion, to contrast Himself with the worldly, crafty world of power-politics, and to tap into a rich vein of biblical imagery describing the nature of God.

But the start of Jesus’ reply to the Pharisees is very different.  To understand this we must understand the meaning of the fox in Jesus’ cultural context.  European tradition emphasizes the cunning of the fox.  This too was a part of the Hebrew tradition.  But there was another way of thinking about the fox in ancient Jewish culture, and that was to compare the fox to the lion.  And immediately, when we place those two animals side-by-side in our mind’s eye, we can see that Jesus is not complimenting Herod on his cunning when He refers to him as “that fox”.  Herod, Jesus is implying, likes to think of himself as one of the big beasts, but he is really just a fox to the Roman Empire’s lion.  Or perhaps Jesus is even implicitly appealing to the tradition of the lion of Judah, a title that would be applied to Jesus in the book of Revelation.  Whether in comparison with the might of Rome, to whom Herod was a mere puppet, or still more in comparison with the cosmic scope of Jesus’ purposes, Herod is not a big beast.  He is a fox rather than a lion.  Make no mistake: Jesus is quite clearly being very rude about Herod.

There is an obvious contrast between these two ways of speaking: the compassionate, maternal imagery that Jesus uses to speak of Jerusalem and its people; and Jesus’ caustic remark comparing Herod to a mangy small-time backyard predator.  A contrast, but not a contradiction.

Not a contradiction because compassion is more complicated than we sometimes recognize.  Not a contradiction because there is a difference between being nice, and being good.

To have compassion for the suffering of others, we do sometimes need to recognize that the causes of that suffering lie in the actions of other people.  We can see this in all sorts of situations, from the domestic to the international.  The instinct of people who are trying to be nice is to seek to smooth things over, to tell people to kiss and make up.  That’s fine in what you might call a six-of-one-and-half-a-dozen-of-the-other situation; but it’s not fine where one party to the conflict is plainly oppressive or abusive.  But if we are interested in being good rather than merely being nice, speaking a hard truth can sometimes be the compassionate and loving thing to do.  Jesus wants the selfish and corrupt religious and political leadership of His day to be recognized for what they are precisely because of His compassion for His people.

And more than that, speaking a hard truth to an abuser or an oppressor is not only compassionate to their victim; it is also compassionate to them.  There is no chance of repentance if there is no recognition of wrongdoing.

Jesus shows us that there is a tough side to genuine compassion.

But we have to be very careful with this.  We have to be very careful, for the simple reason that we are not Jesus!  Speaking hard truths is important; sometimes it may even be justifiable to express ourselves in a caustic and cutting way if this is the only way to get the message across.  But unlike Jesus, we are all too willing to speak in caustic and cutting ways not out of compassion but out of jealousy or hatred or spite or any number of other negative feelings.  Unlike Jesus, our motivations are invariably ego-driven.  And we are even quite good at times at persuading ourselves that we a speaking a hard truth out of compassion when in our heart of hearts we know that we are just being jolly unpleasant.

The most important thing is surely to seek to learn from Jesus the way of compassion and humility.  And perhaps we can at least learn to be a little sceptical of breezy injunctions to “be nice” or to “be kind”, which on occasion are simply insisting that we ignore a palpable injustice or an egregious wrong for the sake of keeping the peace.  There isn’t anything compassionate, still less Christlike, about that.

In the name of the +Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen.